Ebook The Three Temples: On the Emergence of Jewish Mysticism, by Rachel Elior
Accumulate the book The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior begin with currently. But the new means is by collecting the soft file of guide The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior Taking the soft data can be saved or stored in computer system or in your laptop. So, it can be more than a book The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior that you have. The simplest way to reveal is that you can also conserve the soft documents of The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior in your ideal and also offered gizmo. This problem will certainly mean you frequently read The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior in the leisures greater than chatting or gossiping. It will certainly not make you have bad habit, but it will certainly lead you to have much better behavior to check out book The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior.
The Three Temples: On the Emergence of Jewish Mysticism, by Rachel Elior
Ebook The Three Temples: On the Emergence of Jewish Mysticism, by Rachel Elior
Some people might be laughing when looking at you reading The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior in your leisure. Some could be admired of you. And some could really want resemble you which have reading hobby. What concerning your personal feel? Have you really felt right? Reading The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior is a demand and also a leisure activity at once. This problem is the on that particular will certainly make you really feel that you have to check out. If you understand are trying to find the book qualified The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior as the choice of reading, you can locate here.
When obtaining this e-book The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior as reference to read, you can gain not only inspiration yet additionally brand-new understanding and sessions. It has greater than usual advantages to take. What type of publication that you review it will serve for you? So, why need to obtain this e-book qualified The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior in this post? As in web link download, you could obtain the e-book The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior by on the internet.
When obtaining the publication The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior by on the internet, you could review them anywhere you are. Yeah, even you are in the train, bus, hesitating list, or various other locations, on-line publication The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior could be your good friend. Whenever is a great time to read. It will certainly improve your knowledge, enjoyable, amusing, lesson, and experience without spending even more cash. This is why on-line book The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior comes to be most really wanted.
Be the first that are reading this The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior Based on some reasons, reviewing this publication will offer even more benefits. Also you have to review it detailed, page by page, you can complete it whenever and wherever you have time. Once again, this on the internet publication The Three Temples: On The Emergence Of Jewish Mysticism, By Rachel Elior will certainly provide you easy of checking out time and task. It likewise provides the encounter that is budget-friendly to get to and obtain substantially for far better life.
In this ground-breaking study, Rachel Elior offers a comprehensive theory of the crystallization of the early stages of the mystical tradition in Judaism based on the numerous ancient scrolls and manuscripts published in the last few decades. Her wide-ranging research, scrupulously documented, enables her to demonstrate an uninterrupted line linking the priestly traditions of the Temple, the mystical liturgical literature found in the Qumran caves and associated directly and indirectly with the Merkavah tradition of around the second and first centuries BCE, and the mystical works of the second to fifth centuries CE known as Heikhalot literature. The key factor linking all these texts, according to Professor Elior's theory, is that many of those who wrote them were members of the priestly classes. Prevented from being able to perform the rituals of sacred service in the Temple as ordained in the biblical tradition, they channelled their religious impetus in other directions to create a new spiritual focus. The mystical tradition they developed centred first on a heavenly Chariot Throne known as the Merkavah, and later on heavenly sanctuaries known as Heikhalot. In this way the priestly class developed an alternative focus for spirituality, based on a supertemporal liturgical and ritual relationship with ministering angels in the supernal sanctuaries. This came to embrace an entire mystical world devoted to sustaining religious liturgical tradition and ritual memory in the absence of the Temple. This lyrical investigation of the origins and workings of this supernal world is sure to become a standard work in the study of early Jewish mysticism.
- Sales Rank: #929001 in Books
- Brand: Brand: Littman Library Of Jewish Civilization
- Published on: 2005-06-30
- Original language: Hebrew
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: .90" h x 6.10" w x 8.90" l, 1.10 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 312 pages
- Used Book in Good Condition
Review
'Very readable ... This is only the second of Elior's many Hebrew works to be translated into English. Hopefully, it is the harbinger of many more. I recommend this work for inclusion in all academic and theological collections.' Daniel J. Rettberg, AJL Newsletter 'In this major work, senior scholar Rachel Elior demonstrates her sure command over a broad swath of ancient esoteric texts, examining together sources usually treated in isolation ... Elior has put forward a series of incisive ... arguments that are sure to provoke discussion.' G. Spinner, Choice 'This very worthwhile work deserves praise for its breathtaking scope, its bold courage, and its brilliant creativity.' Andrea Lieber, Journal of Religion 'Elior succeeds in her attempt at answering the question constantly discussed in the scholarship on early Jewish mysticism, by and for whom the poetic descriptions of heavenly palaces were written ... What makes her exposition exciting is its reversal of the existing view ... Rachel Elior's sketch of a different picture of early Judaism, which is written with much verve, has opened up many new problems for research. Her book does not merely deal with the origin of Jewish mysticism, but with the foundations of Judaism and thereby, even in its method, breaks down disciplinary barriers.' Gerold Necker, Judaica 'Innovative ... This is an important book for anyone interested in the Qumran sectaries and in the origins of the Jewish mystical tradition. It is well written, lays out its arguments clearly, and can be highly recommended.' Morris M. Faierstein, Religious Studies Review
About the Author
Rachel Elior is Professor of Jewish Philosophy and Mysticism at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. She has been a visiting professor at Princeton, Case Western and Tokyo Universities and has published and edited ten books, the most recent of which is The Three Temples: On the Emergence of Jewish Mysticism. Professor Elior is a senior fellow of the Van Leer Jerusalem Institute.
Most helpful customer reviews
47 of 48 people found the following review helpful.
An important book that could have been a great book
By Geoffrey W. Dennis
In this book, Dr. Rachel Elior does a masterful job of reconstructing the origins of early Jewish(Merkavah) mysticism, tracing it to the priestly spirituality that shaped such Biblical books as Ezekiel and Isaiah, then tracking its evolution in Apocalyptic works such as I Enoch, Jubilees and the Testament of Levi, its mutation into a dualistic, secterian priestly mysticism as expressed in the Dead Sea Scrolls, and finally being "rabbinized" through the Hechalot literature of Merkavah mysticism.
Elior makes a compelling argument, collecting the available data and giving it a coherent, reasonable interpretation. The resulting narrative is so neatly done, in fact, that one is left doubtful only in that it seems so logical that it must, on some level, be an oversimplification. History just isn't usually this tidy. That said, any criticism I could offer would only be only peripheral points. Her thesis seems very sound to me and melds well with the data. This is therefore a very important book, one that dramatically advances our understanding of early Jewish mysticism.
It is an important book, but not a great one, for the simple lack of an assertive editor. This 265 page book needed only to be about 175 pages. The constant repetition of ideas, points, and the same illustrative texts, is both tedious and unnecessary. Elior feels compelled to review the same conceptual clusters (four directions, sevens, Shavuot, the solar calendar of weeks divided into 13, priestly-angels)laundry-list like, every few pages. The Rabbinic text Chagigah 2:1 must be cited, en toto, at least four times.
But this stylistic shortcoming should not prevent one form reading this work. Just be prepared to scan a bit in order to get to the pithy parts.
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful.
Filling the gaps in Jewish mysticism
By Richard J. Grebenc
With this book, Rachel Elior has contributed a great deal to the literature of Jewish mysticism. By taking a fresh look at this area in light of the discovery of, and subsequent work on, the Dead Sea Scrolls, she has done much to round out the picture of the development of Jewish mysticism from the time of Solomon all the way to the time of the Mishnah, and even to the present day.
That being said, I felt there were some omissions. I would have liked to have seen more discussion on how Jewish mysticism in general related to mysticism in other religions of the periods discussed. A footnote (no. 76 on pp.77-78) gives a tantalizing taste of Egyptian, Babylonian, Assyrian, and even Gnostic and Mithraic cosmology, but it is up to the reader to do the additional research. But since little cultural and religious development happens in a vacuum, more detail about external influences intertwined as the book moved along through the stages of history would have been valuable. Additionally, within Judaism, an explanation of the impact of the differing views of the Zadokites and Sages on each other would have been welcome. Chapter nine lists in wonderful detail the stark differences between the different traditions religious and world views, but not a whole lot is said about how they affected each other practically in history. How did they deal with each other over time (we only get the ending)? How much did polemics lead to this deep separation (this is discussed, but only sparingly)?
Also, the author really seems to favor the secessionist view. I do not believe the appropriate balance was struck here. Rather there was a real sense that the rabbis were viewed as heavy-handed in the suppression of the secessionist texts. Even if the rabbis were harsh, more discussion is required as to the underlying reasons. They were defending the truth as they saw it, and the canon that comes down to us today is due to their diligence.
Another rather large oversight was that there is absolutely no mention of the non-priestly class. I think it would have been fascinating and informative to know how the lay person interacted with and viewed the priestly class in both traditions. How did ministering to the people affect the priest's role? How did the populace at large view the priests? Were they regarded with the importance they felt they should have? How did all of this affect the trajectory of the traditions? To read the book, one would barely know there was a laity.
As far as the way the book was edited, I would have liked to have seen more subheadings within chapters, shorter paragraphs, and more tables and charts. Some of the material is tough-going and rather dry, especially when there is in depth discussion about the importance of numbers (see most notably chapter two, but it occurs elsewhere also). Gratefully there are a couple of solar calendar charts and a table of dates dealing with Noah's time on the ark, but otherwise these discussions get bogged down in a morass of dates and numbers. I was grateful to have chapter nine broken down into sections for each of fourteen oppositional characteristics between secessionist and rabbinic texts, but there was only one other chapter that was broken up in more manageable pieces (but just two). Granted this is a scholarly work that will be of little interest to most casual readers, but that doesn't mean that it can't be made more accessible by presenting the material in smaller, more accessible sections. Run on paragraphs may be a part of the challenge of translating from another language, and overall the translator seems to have done a great job, but here again accessibility is aided when the concepts come in smaller packages.
In spite of these criticisms, much of value can be culled out of this book by the careful, interested reader. Filling the gaps in the previously widely accepted version of the development of Jewish mysticism provides the biblical scholar, historian, even archeologist, with food for thought when looking at Judaism over the thirteen or so centuries covered in this volume.
11 of 13 people found the following review helpful.
The Significance of Rituals and Symbols
By S. E. Moore
As as an armchair student of Christianity, this book has given me tremendous insights into ancient rituals which on the surface seem like nonsense if one doesn't understand what they represent. Margaret Barker, a Christian scholar, has done an outstanding job in correlating Jewish Temple rituals with early church liturgies. Rachel Elior, a Jewish scholar, goes into detail about the significance of the solar calendar, the cycle of worship and numerical patterns of the older Temple.
Elior traces the Heikhalot literature, the Merkavah tradition, some of the Qumran writings, and apocalyptic writings to a pre-Hasmonean Zadokite priesthood which placed special emphasis on books such as Chronicles, Ezekiel, Enoch, and Jubilees.
Elior identifies the Qumran community as a disenfranchised Zadokite priesthood who were denied access to the Temple by the Hasmoneans. She rejects the notion that they were comprised of a so called Essene sect which was described by Josephus and Philo.
Elior describes how the Temple services emulated and coincided with the services in Heaven with the Temple representing the universe and the Holy of Holies representing Heaven as illustrated in the Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice found at Qumran. The solar calendar was established in Heaven where it was taught to Enoch and subsequently passed down to Noah, Melchizedek, Levi, and Moses. Adherence to the solar calendar which set the time for worship and festivals and divine numerical patterns was crucial in preserving the covenantal bond between Heaven and earth
Elior explains how the lunar calendar, a product of human intellect introduced by the Hasmonean priesthood and maintained by the more rationalist elements such as the Pharisees and Rabinnic Judaism, threatened to disrupt the harmony between Heaven and earth. The Zadokites thought of themselves as the guardians of a sacred covenant which was in danger of being broken by the Jerusalem priesthood. Much of this is reflected in the Dead Sea Scrolls.
The absence of a physical Temple was a crisis which was resolved by the idea of a Heavenly prototype with the Holy of Holies mystically transformed into the Chariot Throne of Ezekiel's vision. This tradition was carried on by the Qumran community who believed they were a priesthood in exile.
The Pharisees and Rabbinic Judaism, heirs of the rationalist movement, suppressed these ideas by excluding Enoch and Jubilees and claiming prophecy had ended with Haggai, Zechariah, and Malachi.
However, it was the more mystical element of Judaism which inspired the Dead Sea Scrolls and Heikhalot literature. I would add that it was the more mystical element of Judaism which inspired John the Baptist (a prophet from a priestly family) who in turn inspired Jesus and the author of Revelation who undoubtedly had a priestly background.
This book is a valuable resource for anyone interested in a more ancient form of Judaism which spawned the Qumran Community and helped spawn Christianity.
The Three Temples: On the Emergence of Jewish Mysticism, by Rachel Elior PDF
The Three Temples: On the Emergence of Jewish Mysticism, by Rachel Elior EPub
The Three Temples: On the Emergence of Jewish Mysticism, by Rachel Elior Doc
The Three Temples: On the Emergence of Jewish Mysticism, by Rachel Elior iBooks
The Three Temples: On the Emergence of Jewish Mysticism, by Rachel Elior rtf
The Three Temples: On the Emergence of Jewish Mysticism, by Rachel Elior Mobipocket
The Three Temples: On the Emergence of Jewish Mysticism, by Rachel Elior Kindle
